I'd like to discuss interactive whiteboards before reading the article, as this subject is one that I've discussed many times with my great-aunt Rose (and
assuredly will next time I see her at Thanksgiving). She is a public school general elementary teacher, and she teaches a broad category of subjects to kids of varying age groups. This includes music, and she has chosen to use the interactive whiteboard in her classroom. She's told me countless times what an excellent tool it is for interesting kids in music due to all of the fun and varied
applications of it. For instance, she can devote a class to talking about an instrument like the violin. She can use the board to bring up an image of a violin, which she can drag and scroll around with the board, as well as rotate if she has a 3-dimensional model. She can make a bow appear and have students move the bow across the strings in the correct place. She can put a keyboard on the screen, give it the sounds of a violin, and let students come up and experiment with the sound of the violin. The whiteboard also has a lot of functionality as a theory tool; it's less imposing than a piano as you can make the
whiteboard look like whatever you want, and kids naturally want to interact with it. One fun idea she had was letting students drag notes on a staff, and then she could play back what they made on a piano.
Now I'll read the article, and see where it differs from my great-aunt. Well, it did a great job of
explaining HOW to get a whiteboard into the classroom. It's hard to get information on how to acquire technology, especially expensive technology, so that warrants keeping this article. However, it didn't do the best job of opening a teacher's eyes to the uses of the whiteboard. It merely stated what standards could be achieved with the board and gave no examples of how these standards could be met. The best the second article does is offer hints on how to use it, but I wish they gave concrete examples of classroom scenarios.
Still, I'm not totally sold on whiteboards. While it's definitely an exciting tool, a lot of things would come in the budget before the acquisition of a whiteboard. It's more of a
supplement than a necessity. Also, based on my previous experiences with whiteboards, they run the risk of shutting down or not responding to stimulus(
more so than a computer), and that can destroy a lesson plan. If I could have access to one though, I'd definitely use it, especially in an elementary music class like the one I hope to teach.